Marty has been honored for his varied achievements in sports and in the community, including by his induction into six sports Halls of Fame. 

• The Trentonian named Marty one of the all-time top athletes in Trenton. Others honored included Al Downing, Troy Vincent, George Case, and Steve Braun.
• Named the most popular player on three of the Dodgers’ minor league teams he played on and while playing winter ball in the Venezuelan Professional Baseball League.
• Honored as USTA Middle States Player of the Year.
• Recognized by the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown as a member of the American Legion Post 93. national championship team.
• Named Boy Scouts of America, George Washington Council, Man of the Year in 1990.